Video card comparison: 10 things to know before buying a video card

Posted: January 10, 2009 in science & technology
Tags: ,

Unfortunately I’ll have to rebuild my computer a bit earlier than anticipated and planned :( . In the process of researching parts I came across this CNet graphics card page that provides 10 tips on what to focus on when buying a video card – for gaming and non-gaming cards. The page is a couple of years old, but apart from a couple of superseded technical specs it probably is still quite relevant in its overall general focus.

10 Things to know before buying a video card

By James Yu, GameSpot.com on 01 August 2006

Selecting a video card upgrade can be an intimidating task. Unless you’ve kept up with all the GPU announcements and performance reports, it’s practically impossible to know which cards are worth buying.

Graphics processing units, like CPUs, improve year after year, and that means there’s a staggering selection of graphics cards available to choose from and retailers just love to place obsolete cards right alongside the latest and greatest. If you’re not careful, you could very well end up paying a lot of money for technology that’s already a generation behind. Here are 10 things you need to know about video cards before shopping for one.

1. Memory isn’t everything
Here’s the deal. You need a video card that has a decent amount of memory to play games at high-resolution with quality graphics settings enabled. Good video cards usually have lots of memory because all of that GPU horsepower will go to waste if you don’t have enough memory space.

However, the video card manufacturers know that novice buyers look at memory size as one of the main comparison points between different cards, and that’s why it’s very common to see cards with cheap GPUs sporting 256MB or even 512MB of memory, which is sort of like dropping a 110-horsepower engine into the body of a muscle car. The underpowered card might have some of the right numbers on the spec sheet, but its poor performance will show once the gaming starts.

2. It’s all about the GPU
Memory is important, but the real heart of the video card is the graphics processing unit. When you’re browsing through video card names, the most important thing to look for is the GPU type, since that little chip is responsible for all of the video card’s 3D performance. Today’s best GPUs come from Nvidia and ATI, but it’s not enough just to buy a video card with a “Nvidia GeForce” or “ATI Radeon” GPU. You also have to pay attention to the model number since Nvidia and ATI label all their cards from the sub-$100, entry-level cards to the AU$800 high-end monsters with the same GeForce and Radeon brand names. Higher model numbers are better, but you should also pay attention to additional modifiers at the end, such as GT, GS, GTX, XT, and XTX, since they often reveal important shader and clock-speed information. Study a few video card reviews or game performance guides to get familiar with the current models to see how they compare.

3. Pipelines, shaders, and clock speeds
You could look at a GPU’s clock speed and the pixel pipeline count to get a rough idea of the card’s performance level in the early days of 3D acceleration. Today’s GPUs have evolved to do much more than brute-force pixel processing. Lighting and other effects that used to take several pipeline “passes” can now run though a shader program to get the same results with fewer passes and less wasted work. GPUs now have specialised processing units dedicated to crunch through complex vertex and pixel-shader programs. Shader units might become an important specification to watch in future video cards as games become more shader-intensive. ATI has recently started reporting the number of shader units it has assigned to each pixel pipeline in its Radeon X1900 XTX line.

For the time being, you can still judge current GPUs by the number of pixel pipelines they have. GPU manufacturers also report vertex pipelines, but we haven’t seen any games that bottleneck at the vertex-processing level yet. Entry-level cards usually have four pixel pipelines. Midrange cards have 8 or 12 pipelines, and high-end cards have 16 or more pipelines. Higher clock speeds are always better, but if you’re choosing between pipelines or clock speeds, it’s usually better to select more pipes over more MHz. Having eight pipelines running at 400MHz is much better than having four pipelines running at 500MHz.

4. Windows Vista and Direct3D 10
Microsoft plans on shipping its newest Windows operating system, Windows Vista, in early 2007. The new OS will feature DirectX 10, an updated collection of functions that software applications can use to access various system resources, including the 3D graphics card. The new version of DirectX incorporates a new version of Direct3D designed to streamline the graphics pipeline by reducing CPU overhead and moving more work to the GPU. Windows Vista will still work with current DirectX 9 video cards, but you’ll need a DirectX 10 video card to run DX10-enabled games at the best settings.

We expect Nvidia and ATI to ship their first DX10 cards in the second half of this year, but you don’t need to rush out and get one if you’re afraid of game-compatibility problems. Game developers understand that it will be several years before the DX10 installation base surpasses the DX9 installation base. All games, including Vista exclusives Halo 3 and Shadowrun, will be DX9 and DX10 compatible for several years after Vista’s arrival.

5. It’s (almost) always a good time to buy
The fierce competition between Nvidia and ATI has rewarded us with a fast 3D technology development cycle. The GPU manufacturers release a new line of chips every 12 to 18 months, which results in a steady stream of increasingly powerful cards with more and more features. Manufacturers also tweak designs to increase clock speeds and add new features to refresh product lines several months after the initial architecture rollout. Since many new features are forward-looking, such as H.264 high-definition video acceleration and advanced Shader Model support, it might be a year or two before the actual content becomes widely available.

It’s always a good time to buy if you don’t have to get the best card available. Video card prices fall quickly since new product introductions constantly push older or slightly less powerful hardware into more affordable price ranges. The worst-case scenario is buying a high-end card right before Nvidia or ATI release a new line of GPUs, but even then, you still end up with a very powerful card that will have no problem running the games you want to play for a very long time.

6. You don’t need to spend AU$800
The newest top-end cards ship at AU$800 or more, but you can always find several high-performance cards in the AU$350-AU$500 range. This price range usually offers the best performance for the dollar because it includes a mix of current-generation enthusiast-level cards as well as discounted high-end cards from the previous graphics generation.

Check out pipeline and clock speed specifications when comparing two cards from different technology generations. If the specs are roughly the same, go with the newer card since it’ll have support for more advanced features. Newer chip architectures are also more efficient so you’ll get more performance out of the same number of pipelines.

7. Do you have the power?
System power requirements have become a major concern now that video cards have grown into strong, power-sucking behemoths. Video card manufacturers print the power-supply recommendations on the side of the box. The printed number is often slightly higher than actually necessary since it accounts for poor power-supply quality and overloaded systems. Mid- to high-end single cards usually require a 400W or 450W power supply. Requirements for dual-card setups such as a CrossFire Radeon X1900 XTX configuration start at 550W.

8. AGP and PCI Express
Since its introduction two years ago, PCI Express has replaced AGP as the standard graphics slot in currently shipping systems. PCI Express offers two to four times more bandwidth than AGP, and almost all new video cards come in the PCI Express format. The GPU manufacturers throw a bone to AGP system owners once in a while with a new GPU like the Nvidia GeForce 7800 GS, but all the best equipment comes out for PCI Express first.

If your PC system is more than two years old, it probably has an AGP slot. Upgrading to PCI Express will be expensive since you’ll need to replace the motherboard, CPU, and memory, but if your system is more than two years old, it might just be the right time to upgrade your entire PC anyway.

9. SLI and CrossFire
You’ll also need PCI Express if you want to upgrade up to a dual video card configuration. Getting dual-card systems up and running (and showing performance gains) is a complicated matter. You need to have the right kind of motherboard, a compatible set of video cards, and a passable power supply.

Nvidia and ATI both offer competing dual-card formats, which require their own specific motherboards. Nvidia introduced SLI (scalable link interface) first in 2004, and has used the time since then to solidify the platform and even build up an SLI certification program for crucial motherboard, power supply, and memory components. You can pair two SLI-approved GeForce cards from different manufacturers as long as the GPU types match. ATI launched its CrossFire dual-card technology in 2005. As with SLI, CrossFire requires a CrossFire-enabled motherboard, quality memory, and a beefy power supply. Matching ATI cards is slightly more complicated because you need to pair a “CrossFire Edition” card with a “CrossFire Ready” card to get two cards working together.

10. Make sure you actually get a video card
If you’re buying a prebuilt system online, pay careful attention to the video card option. If the selection menu only lists “integrated graphics,” close the browser window immediately and find another model that offers real video card options. Graphics built right onto the motherboard are fine for basic desktop applications like word processing and browsing the Web, but they aren’t powerful enough for gaming unless you consider 15 frames per second at 800×600 acceptable performance.

About these ads
Comments
  1. nerd10101 says:

    I love reading about graphics cards. Especially if it is on a great looking blog. Since I went to your blog why don’t you go to mine :D

    http://nerd10101.wordpress.com/

  2. […] Video Card Comparison Selecting a video card upgrade can be an intimidating task. Unless you’ve kept up with all the GPU announcements and performance reports, it’s practically impossible to know which cards are worth buying. […]

  3. uh says:

    fuck you bitch, you fucking took the work of the original author. you didn’t write this shit

  4. Hank mr bulletproof says:

    Excellent article!!! Thanks for sharing. I learned so much now that I can go out and buy a video card with out feeling like a novice. Kudos to isiria!!! You were very clear that you were sharing the article in the beginning.

  5. Leonardo says:

    Yeah right. Choosing the better, not the best but not good graphics card will be a chance to have a powerful graphics display. If you choose to have a SLI-ready graphics card, you should have SLI-ready motherboards, regarding with this article. Why have to pay for a price with poor performance? Go for your option.

    Just buy for a video card that will fit your needs.

  6. Jeff says:

    Good, solid information thats spot on.
    5. Is a great point as people always ask me when the best time to upgrade is.

  7. dcon says:

    Nice!!! you make me wake up!

  8. antipara says:

    great job isiria.. i extend my warmest thanks to the author of this article.. also to you isiria thank you very much.. i learned a lot.. ^_^

  9. ed says:

    ed here . thank u 4 your taking your time out just 2 help all 2 put are $ where it should go , not 2 a lier. i am dum when it come`s 2 p c so it means a lot 2 me 4 some one 2 takt there time ouit 2 help . so meany people think that there will be a uhal fallowing there hurst , but that just don`t happen so why lie 2 people just 2 get more $$$ when it feel`s so good 2 do the right thing . we all have so much that there is a big $$ maker in storges sheds 2 hold what mean`s nothing really so why cheat others 2 fill 1 more shed . well sorry 4 unloden all that on your time , but what would u be doing if u where not reading this ?? hopefully not lodding a shed like all the others. god bless all. ed

  10. ALBERT NAZARIANS says:

    HELLO DEAR.
    I NEED HELP HOPE YOU CAN HELP ME. REGARDING CHOOSING RIGHT GRAPHIC CARD FOR LARGE 3D ARCHITECTURAL AND MECHANICAL DRAWING FOR RENDERING.
    SO FAR I HAVE TWO ANSWER BUT THEY ARE NOT SURE.
    FIRST THEY TOLD ME NVIDIA QUADRO FX5800 4GB
    SECOND ONE TOLD ME DUAL ATI RADEON HD 5970 2GB GDDR5.
    PLEASE HELP ME TO CHOOSE VERY FAST AND POWERFULL GRAPHIC CARD.I BE HAPPY IF YOU EMAIL ME ASAP.

  11. Caroline Nyokong says:

    Hi,I’ve got a problem that the computer I’m using is showing the message: THE SCREEN SAVER CAN’T RUN BECAUSE IT REQUIRES A NEWER VIDEO CARD OR ONE THAT’S COMPATIBLE WITH DIRECT3D.

    Where can I buy the video card and I’m staying in Gauteng SOUTH AFRICA,PLEASE HELP
    ;

  12. varma says:

    hay i am having ati radeon 9200 256 mb pci card .i put it in the slot .i am having windows 7.
    but the driver is made for xp.i installed it any way.
    now ,i want to know weather it is running or not.

    please answer
    and i also want to know it can run games .

  13. […] crossfire graphic cards isiria.wordpress.com […]

  14. Your site is pretty cool to me and your topics are very relevant. I was browsing around and came across something you might find interesting. I was guilty of 3 of them with my sites. “99% of site owners are guilty of these five errors”. http://is.gd/w4g8Ml You will be suprised how simple they are to fix.

  15. Oh my goodness! Amazing article dude! Thank you, However I am having troubles with your RSS. I don’t understand why I am unable to join it. Is there anybody having identical RSS issues? Anybody who knows the solution can you kindly respond? Thanx!!

  16. Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your blog and in
    accession capital to assert that I acquire actually enjoyed account your blog
    posts. Anyway I will be subscribing to your feeds and
    even I achievement you access consistently rapidly.

  17. にもかかわらずあなたは完璧な私たちスキルと改善あなたのデザインみんなクラフトが多く簡単なトートバッグからバッグ布または重い布素材。スタイリッシュな追加革のストラップの種類と耐久性、が期待どおりに。正直なところ、もの裾できる任意のようなものをスカートまたはカップルジーンズのそれを行う!すべてを行うあなたを参照してください、ステッチ財布作り取ることができる。あなたの進捗状況を継続し、可能性があります合計キットからあなたのローカル工芸品保存またはサーフィンは単純なため独創的なデザイン全体、インターネット。

  18. chanel says:

    キンバリーガーナー古典的なシャネルショルダーバッグが含まれています外観引き出しに、戻るはに適してイベントを格納する飛行機のチケットまたは小規模ノート。ハンドバッグの内部は知られている、ダブルフラップ下で線を描画すると、隠されたジッパーポケットためポケットの中達成するために組織。

  19. Vintage Milf says:

    Superb post however I was wanting to know if you could write a litte
    more on this topic? I’d be very thankful if
    you could elaborate a little bit further.
    Thank you!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s