Haiti – the UN and NGOs are the new tools of neo-imperialism

Posted: March 8, 2009 in civilisation?
Tags: , , ,


By Engler, Yves
Yves Engler’s ZSpace Page
Join ZSpace Haiti can teach you a lot about the harsh reality of social affairs.

From the grips of the most barbaric form of plantation economy sprung probably the greatest example of liberation in the history of humanity. The 1791-1804 Haitian Revolution was simultaneously a struggle against slavery, colonialism and white supremacy. Defeating the French, British and Spanish empires, it led to freedom for all people regardless of color, decades before this idea found traction in Europe or North America.

un-haitiUnfortunately, Haiti’s history also demonstrates how fluidly Europe (and North America) moved from formal colonialism to neo-imperialism. Technically “independent” for more than two centuries, outsiders have long shaped the country’s affairs. Through isolation, economic asphyxiation, debt dependence, gunboat diplomacy, occupation, foreign supported dictatorships, structural adjustment programs and “democracy promotion” Haiti is no stranger to the various forms of foreign political manipulation. Most recently, the elected government of Jean-Bertrand Aristide was destabilized and then overthrown on February 29 2004 by the US, France and Canada, which ushered in a terrible wave of political repression and an ongoing UN occupation.

As we approach the five-year anniversary of the coup, there are three important lessons to be learned from this intervention. First of all, the Canadian sponsored responsibility to protect” doctrine, which many want to encode in international law, is little more than a cover for imperialism. Liberal Party officials justified cutting off aid and invading Haiti by citing a “responsibility to protect” the country, yet the intervention further devastated an already impoverished population.

The second lesson is that “peacekeepers” can be used to wage a brutal class war. In the two years after the coup, UN troops regularly provided vital support for the Haitian police’s violent assaults on poor communities and peaceful demonstrations demanding the return of the elected government. UN forces also participated directly in this violent political pacification campaign, launching repeated anti-“gang” assaults on poor neighborhoods in Port-au-Prince. The two most horrific raids took place on January 6, 2005 and December 22, 2006, which together left some 35 innocent civilians dead and dozens wounded in the densely populated slum of Cité Soleil (a bastion of support for Aristide). In April 2008 UN troops once again demonstrated that their primary purpose in the country was to defend the status quo. During riots over the rising cost of food they put down protests by killing a handful of demonstrators. (Kevin Pina’s film Haiti: The UNtold Story, which will be shown across the country in the coming weeks, documents the chilling brutality of UN forces.)

Finally, Haiti provides an example of how self-described “progressive” Western government-funded NGOs function as an arm of imperialism. A sort of NGO laboratory, Haiti is a highly vulnerable society where NGOs have a great deal of influence. By one estimate, Haiti has the most development NGOs of any country per capita and the vast majority of the country’s social services are run by domestic or foreign NGOs. Their influential position in Haiti provides a clear window into Western government-funded NGOs worst tendencies.

cite-soleilMany NGOs joined the Bush administration, Ottawa and a handful of armed thugs in calling for the removal of Haiti’s democratically elected president in 2004. After repeatedly complaining about human rights violations under the elected government, these groups (Development and Peace, Rights and Democracy, Oxfam Québec, Alternatives etc.) ignored or denied the massive increase in human rights violations that took place in the aftermath of the coup. A January 2008 federal government-funded report published by Alternatives (Québec’s biggest proponent of the World Social Forum) provides an eye into NGOs colonial attitude vis-a-vis Haiti: “In a country like Haiti, in which democratic culture has never taken hold, the concept of the common good and the meaning of elections and representation are limited to the educated elites, and in particular to those who have received citizen education within the social movements.” According to Alternatives, Haitians are too stupid to know what’s good for them, unless, that is, they’ve been educated by a foreign NGO. (For a detailed account of government-funded NGOs role in Haiti see Press for Conversion’s three recent reports or Damning the Flood by Peter Hallward.)

In trying to reason with these groups, one discovers that information or rational argument does little to sway groups receiving millions of dollars from the Canadian government for work in Haiti. Maintaining a progressive agenda in a country considered “high priority” by the power brokers in Ottawa is extremely difficult. And with the intervention into Haiti – unlike say the invasion of Iraq -on few people’s political radar, these NGOs felt limited grass-roots pressure to abandon their government benefactors.

Unlike in Canada Western government-funded NGOs are widely criticized in Haiti. Most progressive minded Canadians see NGOs as part of the solution to global poverty yet where these groups are “helping” out the situation is quite different. Across the country’s political spectrum, Haitians have been highly critical of development NGOs role in undermining the country’s government. A couple months ago the left-wing newspaper Haiti Progrès called NGOs in the country a “mafia” and on February 5 the country’s president, René Préval, called on Washington to stop channeling its assistance through NGOs.

Yves Engler is the author of the forthcoming The Black Book of Canadian Foreign Policy and other books. If you would like to help organize a talk as part of a book tour in May/June Please e-mail: yvesengler@hotmail.com

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]
  1. post-Haiti says:

    Hi, This is a very interesting and from my limited experience in Haiti, spot on post. The NGOs were nothing if not elitists and the UN troops reminded me of thug police in the US that hover around every parade, protest, and gathering. and most of the UN guys that we got to know during our stay were I want to say Pakistani (not sure, can’t remember) and took being stationed in Haiti in exchange for a shorter “sentence,” ie, time as whatever position they were serving. In other words, because Haiti is “so dangerous,” the UN said, we’ll let you serve less time if you make the sacrifice and do your time in Haiti.

    On the flip, I really fell in love — fascination — with the country, the people, the culture. I am going back over the holidays to work with a tiny nonprofit run by a couple of Haitians who actually live in Brooklyn (where I live). It’s located in Leogane. My first time I was in Gonaives helping clean up after the summer/fall ’08 storms.

    What do you think of small, and/or “mom and pop” nonprofits compared to federally funded NGOs? How do their goals and how these are actually implemented in Haiti differ?

    All the best,

  2. WANNA says:

    Deus meu, onde chegamos?
    O homem destruiu a natureza, e agora a natureza destroi os homens!
    Sinto uma angustia muito forte em meu coração quando vejo crianças mortas, porque basicamente nao podem se defender, porem sao anjos que já estão no céu!!
    Esperamos sinceramente que os governos mundiais ajudem este povo que tanto necessita!!!
    Pelo menos podemos orar por eles para que sejam aliviados deste sofrimento , e

  3. Dear Sir

    its umar khosa from pakistan i am the active member of youth parliament of pakistan and working with British Council UK. i am respacting your feelings,

    our youth team is ready for the assistancy of the Haitien People for the rescue of earthquack.


    Muhammad Umar khosa

  4. […] Haiti’s problems on poorly managed charity or  as a modern form of imperialism! See, e.g., here, here, and […]

  5. camlia says:

    we should help hati so that it can get bak on its feet. i believe in the pharse the more u give the more u recieve. please help the most u cani am. GOD BLESS HATI ❤

  6. cynthia says:

    omqq every little thing thats happeninq to earth should mak us more sure on how to help earth. Knowing that kids are staving and dieing we SHOULD MAKE A DIFFERNCE WE CAN HELP!!

  7. Michael says:

    Melange, You should definitely come here, and we need to let the rest of the world know about this. Michael


  9. i wishi can take on of the haiti kids

  10. jesse says:

    is that guy dead on the ground?

  11. donna says:

    they are people they need to be helped

  12. […] to be independent? Can this state of affairs instead effectively be critiqued as representing a particularly insidious form of neo-liberalism, one dressed in the culturally (in)sensitive garb of Euro(American)-centric neo-colonialism? If so, […]

  13. Replay says:

    So what really makes on line slots so extraordinary? Is playing on-line casino slots special? And there are online slots that are providing online and animated slot games. So there appears to be no reason at all to create the live dealer version, right? Because it is better! It is amongst the very best casino games that most on line casino gamers around the globe love to play. This is a challenging and exciting on line casino game, that makes it a real favourite all around the on-line casino arena. An online casino site is basically nothing if it doesn’t provide whatever kind of on-line one arm bandit games.

    With bonus features and winning combinations, you could possibly be given free deposits in just a few slot games at on line casino sites that you possibly can join at no cost. This could be terrific technique to move from slots free to paying slots, since, you have learnt playing slot machines from free slot game on-line, and received just a few bonus incentive in order to play more, and for the real cash, with out even risking your own cash. Free on-line slots on the net are free to take part in. Hence, you don not need to risk whichever sum of cash and enjoy and win a few bucks at the same time all from the comfort of your very own abode. Free slots are good method to learn ways one can play the slot machines, and are simply unbelievable to pass the time. If you need to look for the best site that offer the best on line slots without cost then enter ‘free slots’ on google and go to Slots 4U.com. There, you would certainly find various types of the very best on line slots on the internet. Figuring ways you could enjoy slot games on-line is piece of cake, hardest part is ways one could stop playing!

  14. […] Haiti’s problems on poorly managed charity or  as a modern form of imperialism! See, e.g., here, here, and […]

  15. […] Haiti’s problems on poorly managed charity or as a modern form of imperialism! See, e.g., here, here, […]

  16. […] teksta kanadskog pisca i političkog aktivista Yvesa Englera, objavljenog 8. ožujka 2009. na isiria.wordpress.com, skoro godinu dana prije potresa koji je pogodio Haiti. Tekst daje kratak pregled povijesti Haitija […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s